Jump to content


Remembered Today:

Photo

Valhalla (Manchester Rgt contemporary account republished)


2 replies to this topic

#1 John Hartley

John Hartley

    General

  • Old Sweat
  • 14,592 posts

Posted 24 February 2012 - 03:27 PM

Walter Hulme wrote the account of his war service in 1918 and published it privately for friends and family. It is now edited and republished on behalf of the Manchester Regimental Collection and can be purchased from the Regimental Museum (and, presumably, other sources).

I was immediately attracted to it as the modern edition ascribes Hulme’s service to “D” Company of the 2/6th Battalion, Manchester Regiment, the history of which is included in my book “Not a Rotter in the Lot”.

However, and it is a big “however, as soon as I started to read it, I realised something was wrong. The places that Hulme talks about were not places where the 2/6th served. He writes of service around the Somme, in the autumn of 1917 – at which time the 2/6th was very firmly in Belgium. Nothing of the places or timeframe mentioned by Hulme ties in with the known facts (including his wounding at Beaumont Hamel in early/mid December 1917 – when the 2/6th was around Ypres)

It appears that Hulme initially trained with the 2/6th and, later, was an active member of its Old Comrades Association and I can only presume that the editor has made assumptions about his service, based on that. The medal roll at Kew would confirm the battalion Hulme actually served with but it cannot have been the 2/6th.

So, that would seem to me to lessen its worth as an account other than as yet another story written in the flowery language of the time – long on moody feeling, short on factual detail. Presumably, if the Regimental Collection undertakes some basic research to identify the correct unit then that would be more useful if there was a reprint at some time.

#2 gallipian

gallipian

    Sergeant

  • Members2
  • 42 posts

Posted 28 February 2012 - 08:38 PM

the editor and owner of the only known copy is robert bonner,robert is aware of the fact that walters story doesnt tie in with the 2/6th battalions movements,if you had popped over to our manchester regt forum,we could have helped you with your querie,monsstar[roy] found out that walter was in the 22nd battalion,he was also entitled to the TFWM,if we can help with any research or questions,pop along to our forum,we are always glad to be of help

mack

#3 John Hartley

John Hartley

    General

  • Old Sweat
  • 14,592 posts

Posted 28 February 2012 - 09:30 PM

Such a shame that Robert hadnt been able to identify the correct battalion before the book was published. Still that's something that he can correct when there's a reprint. In the meantime, with the Regimental Museum still marketing it on their website as a 2/6th book, there must be a worry that potential customers will be misled.