Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Is this a Great War ship?
Great War Forum > The soldiers and armies of the Great War > Ships and navies
trin1054
Evening all,
found this photo in a box of assorted pictures. It has a silvery tint in certain light which may age it. The tower appears to be some kind of canvas affair.

I've no idea of it's age - any help much appreciated!

Cheers,

Marc

Click to view attachment

trin1054
...bit more of a close-up. No scanner, sorry!

Click to view attachment
truthergw
The 'canvas' is an anti-shrapnel device. In the sense of shell fragments.
trin1054
QUOTE (truthergw @ Oct 28 2009, 08:25 PM) *
The 'canvas' is an anti-shrapnel device. In the sense of shell fragments.


Thnks for that - when I fist saw it I wondered if it was some kind of mock-up training ship! I'm a complete dunce when it comes to naval stuff.

Is this device Great War period?

Cheers,

Marc
centurion
Queen Mary or Princess Royal ?
Stanley_C_Jenkins
The square structure on top of the tripod mast makes it look like one of the "later" Dreadnoughts, perhaps HMS Warspite, HMS Barham or one of their sisters in the Queen Elizabeth class.
trin1054
Thanks for the suggestions - I'll try and do some research based on these.

Cheers!
centurion
Also take a look at Revenge - which had a similar circular housing above the square one. Unfortunately all that padding obscures the detail
ionia
Perhaps PRINCESS ROYAL late in the war?
auchonvillerssomme
There appears to be another ship of the same configuration in the background.

Mick
simonharley
Can you take a close-up of the officers? I fancy I can spot a cap at a jaunty angle, which would be Beatty, and the dour expression of Chatfield, making the ship "Lion".

Simon
trin1054
QUOTE (simonharley @ Oct 29 2009, 10:56 AM) *
Can you take a close-up of the officers? I fancy I can spot a cap at a jaunty angle, which would be Beatty, and the dour expression of Chatfield, making the ship "Lion".

Simon


I'll certainly have a go tonight after work.

Thanks
Martin Elliget
It's funny, isn't it - a photo of a few hundred men and yet you can pick out the authority of the commanding officer (appears to be about the only man crossing his arms). Oh, yes, and he's on the bridge smile.gif
simonharley
Just to clarify, all the officers are seated in the second row!

Simon
Martin Elliget
Hang my head in shame, Simon! You're absolutely right. In my feeble defence, I had gone to the most recent post (yours) and then scrolled back up to the cropped photo. I was assuming that was the original one posted. When I was trying to roughly estimate the number of men, the thought did occur to me that there were too few men for the class of ship mentioned!
DulcetTone
It is not Queen Mary, as the ship's foretop has something fancy perched atop it. Possibly PR or Lion.
Its director platform is below the foretop, which is indicative (maybe not exclusively) of these ships.

tone
MikeBeehan
Its a wonderful picture though isn't it! smile.gif
trin1054
QUOTE (simonharley @ Oct 29 2009, 10:56 AM) *
Can you take a close-up of the officers? I fancy I can spot a cap at a jaunty angle, which would be Beatty, and the dour expression of Chatfield, making the ship "Lion".

Simon


You're absolutely bang-on with Beatty, Simon - nice work!

Click to view attachment

From Wikipedia:

Click to view attachment

My close-up does no justice to the real photo where the faces are crystal clear.

Looks like Chatfield too but less certain (again from Wiki):

Click to view attachment

Many thanks,

Marc
trin1054
...and sure enough Google confirms the answer here

Thanks to all!
per ardua per mare per terram
For other pictures see: http://www.battleships-cruisers.co.uk/hms_lion.htm
simonharley
QUOTE (trin1054 @ Oct 29 2009, 05:42 PM) *
...and sure enough Google confirms the answer here

Thanks to all!


I think your photo's far more interesting. Scan it for posterity! smile.gif

Simon
DulcetTone
QUOTE (trin1054 @ Oct 29 2009, 01:42 PM) *
...and sure enough Google confirms the answer here

Thanks to all!


That image shows fairly clearly that the ship in background left is Tiger, owing to the wall of funnels.

tone
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.